Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Belicoso Review

2026-07-02  Hand-Me-One · 2/4 My Money

Verdict: Hand-Me-One (2/4). There's a genuinely good cigar in here... the first third was excellent... but a weird burnt-nut note, some bite on the sides of my tongue, and a torch that never got to stay in my pocket kept it from being a yes.

The Don Carlos line is Fuente's tribute blend... African Cameroon wrapper over Dominican binder and filler. The Belicoso runs 5 3/8 x 52 with the tapered head.

The Setup

• Cigar: Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Belicoso (5 3/8 x 52, Cameroon wrapper)
• Street price: ~$15.50 for a single online... Fuente holds pricing tight, so it's about the same number everywhere
• What I paid: $15... my own money, nobody sent me this
• Storage: 69% RH in my Herf-a-Dor
• When/where: 8pm, after dinner
• Food beforehand: sausage and pepperoni pizza around 6:30
• First cigar of the day

Light Up and First Third

Chocolate and nuts on the light, no spice at all, very smooth. The chocolate disappears quickly and nuttiness comes to the front with a natural tobacco sweetness... light pepper on the retrohale and a really nice lingering sweetness on the palate. The nuttiness is sweet, almost peanuts. A tiny bit of dustiness showed up partway through. Honestly, excellent through the first third. If the whole cigar smoked like this, we'd be done here and the answer would be yes.

Second Third

Here's where it turned. The nuttiness picked up a roasted... sometimes flat-out burnt... character, and the dustiness stuck around. Light pepper still on the retro. As the third went on, the burnt edge backed off toward roasted nuts, and that pleasant sweetness kept lingering underneath. Good, but I kept waiting for the burnt note to come back.

Final Third

It did. The final third kept the roasted nut core with a bit more pepper on the retrohale and the same lingering sweetness, but the flavor kept switching back and forth between sweet nuts and burned nuts... and I couldn't tell you why. On top of that I started getting a bite on both sides of my tongue, which was a weird sensation and not a welcome one.

Construction

• Wrapper: good and smooth, though it cracked a little with the cut and part of it stuck to the band.
• Draw: started tight. I couldn't find my draw tool, so yes... I ran a screw into it. Worked. After that, zero resistance.
• Burn: stacking dimes when it behaved, but it got wonky at the end of the first third and needed a touch-up, then a few more through the second and final thirds. One side of the wrapper just didn't want to burn. Call it four or five trips to the torch.
• Ash: decent... held on firmly through each third and came off clean with a tap.
• Smoke output: fine, no complaints.

Bottom Line

The first third is legitimately great... sweet, nutty, smooth, classic Cameroon. But the back half kept flashing that burnt-nut note, the tongue bite showed up late, and babysitting the burn with a torch all night isn't my idea of relaxing. Fuente's reputation says this deserves another shot... maybe I got one with a construction issue driving the burnt flavor. But I'm not rushing back.

Would I smoke it again? Hand-Me-One. If one showed up in front of me I wouldn't turn it down... I'm just not ordering more with my own money until a second one proves the burnt note was a fluke.

Best for: an after-dinner smoke for somebody who loves sweet, nutty Cameroon profiles and has the patience to keep a torch handy. Pairs naturally with coffee.

My rating scale, one question only... would I spend my own money on this again? 4 Box Buy (box on hand, always) / 3 Five-Pack (yes, a few live in the humidor) / 2 Hand-Me-One (wouldn't buy it, wouldn't turn one down) / 1 Not Even Free (I'd rather smoke nothing).

More reviews