Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour Toro Review

2026-07-02  Hand-Me-One · 2/4 My Money

Verdict: Hand-Me-One (2/4)... and that's mostly about Davidoff money. Nothing offensive about it. That's kind of the problem. It's a one-dimensional, thin-smoking, burn-fussy cigar that never gave me a reason to buy another one at this price.

The Late Hour is Davidoff's "Winston working past midnight" concept... Ecuadorian Habano wrapper, Mexican San Andres binder, Dominican and Nicaraguan fillers, with some of the tobacco aged in single malt scotch casks. Sounds like it should be interesting. Hold that thought.

The Setup

• Cigar: Davidoff Winston Churchill The Late Hour, Toro (6 x 54)
• Street price: ~$29.50 for a single online... CI quietly moves 5-packs at about $19.40/stick, the only real discount lane on this cigar
• What I paid: full retail at a local B&M... the online single price plus tax, my own money, which is exactly why the price keeps coming up
• Storage: 69% RH in my Herf-a-Dor, about 72°F inside
• When/where: evening, and it was 90-something degrees and a little humid outside... I'll give it that as a partial excuse on the burn
• Food beforehand: chicken parm from LongHorn, then a San Pellegrino
• First cigar of the day

Light Up and First Third

Cold draw was light and sweet. On the light... zero spice. I mean take a big mouthful of smoke, blow the entire thing out through your nose, and there's not an ounce of spice in it. What's there is a light nutty sweetness with maybe a hint of coffee on the backside. And on a slow single-puff retrohale I kept getting one very specific thing: straight peanut shells.

Partway through the first third I'd already noticed the draw was a little tight for my taste and the flavor was one-dimensional. Not bad. Not offensive. Just... the same. I actually considered getting up and grabbing a different cigar, and the only reason I didn't was what I paid for this one.

Second Third

Still sweet, now with a slightly acrid edge on the finish, and I finally put my finger on the other issue... the smoke had been really thin the entire time. Right at the halfway point a touch of spice finally showed up on the retrohale... you could still comfortably blow the whole draw out your nose... and the smoke thickened up a little. Sweet nuttiness, both mellower now, with that faint acrid finish hanging around.

Final Third

The most life the cigar showed. A little actual spice (still mild), the nutty sweetness and coffee both ramped up some, and the acrid note faded out. Smoke output finally reached what I'd call normal-ish. Still that peanut-shell core. It ended pleasant and completely unremarkable.

Construction

• Wrapper: fine, no issues to report.
• Draw: a little tight for my preference the whole way.
• Burn: the real headache. One side kept burning an inch ahead of the other... at one point one side was an inch in and the other barely a half inch. I touched it up three or four times and it never really straightened out, even with the slow side positioned to burn faster. The heat outside may share some blame, but a cigar at this price should handle it.
• Ash: ashed it early trying to manage the uneven burn.
• Smoke output: thin for two-thirds of the cigar, only normal near the end.

Bottom Line

I kept waiting for the scotch-barrel aging to show up and do something. It never did. This is a mild-plus, sweet, nutty, peanut-shell cigar with thin smoke and a burn that made me work all night... and at a budget price I'd shrug and say it's a decent easy smoke. At Davidoff money? No. Boring is the one thing a cigar this expensive isn't allowed to be.

Would I smoke it again? Hand-Me-One. If somebody hands me one, it's a perfectly pleasant background smoke. Buy another at this price? No... it never gave me a reason.

Best for: somebody who wants the Davidoff band on a very mild, low-effort evening smoke and doesn't care what it costs. If you want flavor progression for that money, look elsewhere.

My rating scale, one question only... would I spend my own money on this again? 4 Box Buy (box on hand, always) / 3 Five-Pack (yes, a few live in the humidor) / 2 Hand-Me-One (wouldn't buy it, wouldn't turn one down) / 1 Not Even Free (I'd rather smoke nothing).

More reviews