Learn ›
Learn · Smoking BasicsFirst-Year Cigar Mistakes
The expensive first-year mistakes weren't technique... they were buying mistakes. Technique costs you one cigar at a time. Buying wrong costs you a shelf.
Mistake one: I only bought one kind of cigar
My first year, I bought Connecticut shade almost exclusively. Mild, approachable, and every tobacconist I told "I just started smoking" steered me to another one. That's the standard beginner script, and I think it's wrong. It's like telling someone who just started eating solid food to stick to grilled chicken... forever.
The cost showed up later. Once I finally tried a sun grown, a criollo, a corojo, a maduro, an oscuro, I realized how much map I'd been ignoring... and my palate moved. Today a lot of Connecticuts come off bitter to me, and a good one is genuinely good but rare on my shelf. I still have unsmoked Connecticuts from that first wave. If it clicked for you with one mild cigar, great... now buy six different wrappers, two of each, and find out what you actually like before you own a box of anything. The wrapper pages exist for exactly this.
Mistake two: I trusted the price tag
The most expensive cigar I've bought ran about fifty dollars. It was good, for the record. But I've had twelve-dollar cigars on par with it or better, and I've disliked more $25 to $30 cigars than I've liked. Price told me almost nothing, and I spent a lot of money learning that... some of those expensive misses are still sitting in my humidor because I can't bring myself to smoke them or throw them out.
Run the math the way I do now: a $30 cigar over an hour and a half is $20 an hour to sit in a chair. If it doesn't hit, that stings. A $10 cigar that hits is the better evening every time. This site's review history says the same thing... our priciest review to date scored below cigars costing a third as much. If one lesson would have saved me the most money, it's this one.
Mistake three: I re-wet my humidity packs
Storage I mostly got right, by accident: I never bought a wooden humidor. Bags, then a humidor bag, then weather-tight food containers, and I'd rather spend the wood-box money on cigars. But I did try to revive spent two-way humidity packs, and it worked fine right up until it didn't. I never lost a batch of cigars. I very easily could have. The packs are engineered to hold a set point; a re-wet pack just holds a point, and you don't know which one. Replace them. It's the cheapest insurance in the hobby.
Mistake four: I cut way too deep
Consistently, way too deep, and I ruined some good cigars doing it. The cap on a cigar is shallow, and a straight cutter with open rails invites you to take off a third of an inch when a dime's width is the job. If I started over I'd buy either a V-cutter, which physically can't go too deep, or one of the guillotines with a backstop... you set the head against the flat side and it only lets you clip the right amount. How to cut a cigar has the full picture.
What I got right, so you can copy it
Lighting. I watched a pile of videos before my first cigar and learned to toast the foot instead of torching it. Never had the charcoal-mouth first third people complain about. Jam a torch straight into the foot and you taste scorch for twenty minutes. Toast, then light.
Pace... eventually. Early on I puffed too fast when I was into a conversation and too slow when I wasn't, and got hot harsh smoke or a dead cigar for it. Roughly a puff a minute is the lane. It becomes automatic; give it a few cigars.
Retrohaling, on mild cigars. It took me forever to learn to retrohale, mostly because half the people explaining it online clearly don't do it. The accidental genius was learning on mild Connecticuts... when you inevitably push too much smoke through your nose, a mild cigar forgives you and a spice bomb makes you pay. Learn it on something gentle. It opens up a world of flavor you're currently missing.
The pattern, if you want it
Every mistake on this list came from moving faster than my information. Buying deep before my palate settled, trusting price as a proxy, improvising storage chemistry, cutting before learning where the cap ends. The cigars were never the problem. The hurry was.
Keep reading
Reviewed at WSA since this page was written
Padrón 1926 Serie 40th Anniversary Maduro Review
Verdict: Five-Pack (3/4)... a genuinely great cigar that only two things keep off a box: the price, and a quick fall-off right at the end. This is an excellent cigar, layered and evolving the whole way, and it does a thing almost nothing else does: it rewards a single slow puff s