The Deals Inbox: What 60 Days of "Deals" Actually Look Like
Every night, every cigar email that lands in the deals inbox gets run through the rules. Since August 24, every email that fails gets logged with the reason. This page counts 60 days of the deals page, August 16 to October 14, plus the 52 nights of that log inside it. It says what I suspected when I built the thing... most "deals" aren't.
The short version
From August 16 to October 14, the deals page posted 458 deals, about seven a night. One night had none.
For the 52 of those nights with a rejection log (August 24 on):
- 509 cards made the page (400 deals, plus 109 new-release and restock notices).
- 1,053 emails didn't. That's about 20 a night that came in and produced nothing.
- So at best, about one email in three produced anything. A card is one offer and a single email can carry several, so if anything that number flatters the inbox.
Why they got cut
| What was wrong with it | Emails | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Same offer again (repeats, same-day resends, permanent bins) | 358 | 34% |
| Not a sale at all (browse-bait, off-topic, events, a competitor's roundup) | 204 | 19% |
| "Up to X% off" with nothing behind it | 194 | 18% |
| No price anywhere | 145 | 14% |
| Free stuff, points or shipping instead of a lower price | 79 | 8% |
| A real offer with no page to send you to | 56 | 5% |
| Already dead by post time | 17 | 2% |
The biggest bucket isn't fake deals. It's old deals. A third of everything that came in was something I had already posted, something that never goes away, or the same email sent twice in one day. One retailer sent a near-identical email three times in one day, then did it again the next day.
Of the 145 with no price, 86 had whatever price there was inside a picture, with nothing in the text to read, search or check. If the price is a JPEG, there's nothing for me to post.
One sale, 46 names
One retailer emailed on all 52 nights, 89 emails in all, usually some version of "up to 89% off, as low as $1.49 a cigar, plus free shipping." The sale had 46 different names. Price Slicer. Price Trimmer. Price Pruner. Price Crusher. Price Buster. Price Plunge. Price Drop. Wet Your Beak. Beak-Soaking Discounts. Fall Harvest. Fall Into Savings. Fall Sunday. Same number, every time.
"Up to 89%" means something, somewhere in the store, is 89% off. It tells you nothing about the cigar you came for, and that's the whole point of the rule against storewide "up to" blasts. In 52 nights, exactly one thing from that sender made the page, and it was a free lighter with a box.
It isn't alone, just the loudest. Another sender, an outdoors store that sometimes carries cigars, also mailed on all 52 nights. In the one week those got opened and read, every single one was hunting gear, knives or sunglasses.
Last chance, again
82 of the rejected emails had urgency in the subject line: last chance, last call, final hours, today only. 40 of those were an offer already posted, a resend of an earlier email that same day, or a bin that never closes. The clock was running on something that wasn't going anywhere.
It gets better. 15 times a retailer re-sent an offer I'd already posted, and the number had gotten worse. A 10-pack I posted at $44.99 came back at $49.99 eight times over the next three weeks, still dressed up as a sale. A 63% off came back as 59%. Same product, less discount, louder email.
And the personal touch. Eight times in one month, one retailer sent a coupon "just for you" with a countdown timer. They came in pairs: "Ready for $20 off?" one day, "One more chance... today only!" the next. Four pairs, a new code each round. Personal codes never go on the page. These didn't feel very personal.
Who sends vs. who delivers
The five noisiest senders account for half of everything that got cut. The five that produced the most cards on the page are mostly big senders too, because volume is volume:
| Retailer | Cards on the page | Emails cut |
|---|---|---|
| Cigar Page | 60 | 137 |
| Cigars International | 57 | 43 |
| Corona Cigar Co. | 48 | 74 |
| Thompson Cigar | 45 | 101 |
| Perfect Cigar Blend | 40 | 11 |
The efficient ones mail less. Atlantic Cigar put 25 cards on the page against 4 emails cut. Perfect Cigar Blend, 40 against 11. CigarBid, 30 against 16. When they do mail, it usually makes the page.
When it lands
Back in the summer I had 60 days of my own inbox (mid-May to mid-July) broken down by send time: 649 retailer emails. They come in two waves, roughly 8 to 11 AM and 1 to 6 PM, with a lull at lunch. One retailer's daily email hit at 11:02 AM on 61 of 61 days. By 10 AM only about a quarter of the day's mail has arrived.
That's why the deals page goes up at 6:30 PM and not at breakfast. By then about 95% of the day's mail is in.
I did buy a box off a deal in this stretch. It never came in an email at all. It was a 25%-off code that only lived on one retailer's homepage banner. That's why the nightly run now checks a couple of homepages too.
Do the real ones beat street price?
This is the part I care about, because every verdict here is judged at street price and a deal only matters if it beats that.
Of the 458 deals, 9 linked to a line I've reviewed, so I could check them against my own street number. Five gave a price and a count I could turn into a per-stick number. All five came in under my street price, by 18% to 54%, sometimes in a different size or edition of the same line. The cleanest one: the My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro, same size I reviewed, at about $6.70 a stick against $11 street.
Three of the other four said only "30% off MSRP," "35% off" or "50% off MSRP." The fourth gave box prices with no box sizes. I can't check those, and neither can you without clicking through. MSRP is the manufacturer's number, not the market's, and plenty of cigars never sell at it, so a percentage off it tells you less than it sounds like.
What I take from it
The real deals are real. Every one I could check against my own street price beat it, some by a lot. They're just buried under a pile twice their size: the same sale with a new name, prices in pictures, and clocks that never run out.
That's the job the page does. I'd rather the nightly run read those 1,053 emails than do it myself.
More from the Deck
Why Your Cigar Has a Tight Draw
17 of my 49 cigar reviews needed a tool down the middle, and it fixed about half. Plugs vs tight bunches, what happens at the bench, and the verdict cost.
Why I Smoke Cigars
I smoke cigars to slow down: no screens, an hour and a half after dinner, flavor over strength. Why I started, and how it shapes the way I review.
Why Your Cigar Burns Uneven
When my cigars burn crooked, the notes keep pointing at how they were rolled, not the wind or the lighter. What goes wrong at the factory, and the cost.