Are you 21 or older?

This site discusses cigars. You must be of legal smoking age to enter.

Latest review: Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro →
One question. Answered honestly.
Cigar Review

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro Review

2026-11-14  Five-Pack · 3/4 My Money · by Eric

Filed under: Cigar Bands · CT Broadleaf · Dominican Republic · Figurados · Fixing a Wavy Burn · Burn Time by Size · Ligero / Seco / Viso · Maduro Is a Process · One Draw or Two · The Ash · Retrohale · Ash and Flavor · Strength vs Body · The Draw · The Nub · Which Size, When

Verdict: The Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $21 street... rich, fudgy chocolate from the light to the nub with almost no bitterness, held out of a box by the price and by a profile that stays in one delicious lane the whole way. I liked it enough that I ordered a ten-count box of the longer Masterpiece while I was still smoking it. That box was on sale, and a sale isn't how this gets judged.

Brand
Arturo Fuente
Line
Hemingway Maduro
Vitola
Untold Story
Size
7 5/8 x 54
Wrapper
Connecticut Broadleaf Maduro
Binder
Dominican
Filler
Dominican
Made in
Dominican Republic
Factory
Tabacalera A. Fuente y Cía (Santiago)
Strength
Mild-plus building to about medium
Street price
$21
Unlit Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro held in hand against a stone wall, very dark brown wrapper, red and gold A. Fuente Gran Reserva band over a black and gold lower band, long perfecto with a tapered foot
Very dark brown, a little splotchy, and rustic looking. Double cap, tapered foot.

I'd never had this cigar before. In September the natural Hemingway Short Story landed a Hand-Me-One here, and I said then that I'd give the Maduro a proper look. The natural Hemingway wears a Cameroon wrapper, and I can't think of a Cameroon cigar where I've said, I really like that one. The Maduro trades the Cameroon for Connecticut Broadleaf over Dominican binder and filler, rolled at Tabacalera A. Fuente in Santiago. The Untold Story is one of the big ones in the line, a 7 5/8 x 54 perfecto.

The Setup

  • Cigar: Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro, perfecto, 7 5/8 x 54. Connecticut Broadleaf maduro wrapper, Dominican binder, Dominican filler. Rolled at Tabacalera A. Fuente y Cía in Santiago, Dominican Republic.
  • Street price: about $21 for a single online. Five-packs run about $98 to $105, and a box of 25 is a little over $500.
  • What I paid: I don't remember the exact number. I bought it as a single at a local brick-and-mortar shop, and I'm sure I paid a few dollars over sticker for it. My own money.
  • Storage: my Herf-a-Dor at 69% RH. It's been in there around nine months.
  • When/where: started about 12:45 on a brisk Saturday afternoon on the back deck. 44°, feels like 36. That feels-like number is the wind, and there was no wind at all where I was sitting. I had a fire going, so it was substantially warmer than that.
  • Smoke time: about an hour and 45 minutes.
  • Food beforehand: scrambled eggs and hash browns around 9:30, a blueberry muffin around 10 or 10:30, and some coffee with it. It had been a little while since I'd eaten anything.
  • First cigar of the day, paired with water. Cut with the Xikar XO, lit with my Jetline Rubanno single-flame torch.

Light Up and First Third

I had time today, so I was hoping this one was delicious, because I wanted a great, enjoyable cigar for a few hours.

It's a very dark brown wrapper, slightly splotchy in color, and very rustic looking. The cap looks like a double cap, and it's a tapered foot. At first I only saw a little bit of toothiness. A few minutes in, sitting there with it, I realized it's actually a pretty toothy stick. It had been in the shade a little when I first looked at it.

Close-up of the Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro wrapper while it burns, a toothy, rustic dark brown leaf with gray ash at the foot and a fire blurred in the background
The tooth I didn't notice when it was in the shade.

I cut it with the Xikar XO and got a good, clean cut. The cold draw was very tight, but it's basically a closed foot, so you'd expect that. It was a very, very sweet cold draw, with a plum-like flavor when I retrohaled it, and very sweet when I licked my lips.

On the light, when it was barely lit, I got rich dark chocolate, a touch of black licorice, and a tiny bit of red pepper spice. It reminded me of a Mexican hot chocolate. A very rich chocolate.

Once it was lit, a single draw had a light red pepper flavor with a tiny bit of spice... more the flavor of red pepper than the spice. Some chocolate, and a touch of leather on the finish. A double draw had a slightly stronger red pepper flavor with no extra spice, leather, and an underlying sweetness I couldn't place. The retrohale was very smooth, with no spice at all: rich dark chocolate, cream, and just a touch of coffee and then leather. A very light leather lingers on your palate. It was very good right from the start, and a very smooth cigar. Strength was mild-plus while I was burning through the tapered tip.

Just before I got to the end of the tip, I took a full, deep draw and retrohaled the entire thing, instead of my normal half to a quarter of it. There was maybe a touch of spice on it, and it was absolutely delicious. Heavy, rich chocolate, a touch of red pepper flavor with barely any spice at all, leather and cream, and some coffee in there to round it out.

At the end of the point, the profile had shifted a little. On a single draw the red pepper flavor was the prominent note... flavor, not spice, because there's very little spice... with chocolate right behind it. Leather takes over on the finish, with just a touch of coffee and a touch of cream. A double draw was basically the same profile, but after the chocolate a minerality comes out for a little bit, then fades into very light leather, light coffee, and light cream.

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro burning with gray ash covering the tapered tip, band on, held in front of a stone fireplace with a fire behind the screen
The end of the tapered tip, right before I knocked it off.

Whenever I light a tapered tip, it never burns evenly. I don't know if that's tapered tips in general, because it's such a small piece to light at the end, or if it's me and I have no idea how to light them properly. It's probably me. So I always knock the tip off afterwards and get it even. It's not a knock on the cigar.

This one was actually burning pretty good, just a touch crooked. I knocked the tip off and touched it up so it was even. It was almost to the point where I wouldn't have worried about it. If I'd been smoking it without doing a review, I probably wouldn't have touched it up at all. It wasn't really uneven, just slightly off. It's probably one of the best burn lines on a tapered point that I've had. And there was a nice point from the ligero on it after I ashed it.

The retrohale after that was absolutely delicious. Super thick, rich, creamy chocolate, almost fudgy in texture. A tiny bit of red pepper flavor and no spice at all, and that's on a deep draw with the whole thing going through my nose. Somehow it gets richer on the chocolate finish, then cream comes in, and in the background there's a touch of leather and a touch of coffee. But it is just heavy chocolate, fudgy deliciousness.

At the end of the first third, a single draw had a touch of licorice, chocolate, red pepper flavor with basically no spice, some leather, and some coffee. A double draw was the same thing, except the black licorice was mingled with a little minerality at the beginning. On a deep retrohale there was a touch of spice now, a super mild red pepper, with that heavy, dark, rich chocolate. As the red pepper fades, the chocolate just keeps increasing, into that thick, fudgy chocolate. Leather, coffee, and cream are mingled on the finish, but the main tone is still that fudgy, rich chocolate. Super good. It was smoking like a dessert cigar.

The draw was a touch tight. Just a touch. I had a draw tool sitting there and didn't grab it. When I say a touch tight, I mean it was very acceptable, just slightly tighter than I want it to be. I'd have liked it a hair more open.

Second Third

About halfway through the second third I ashed it, and it was just a little bit crooked, so I touched it up again to keep it straight. It wasn't racing ahead or anything like that. One side was just a little bit slow. It probably wasn't necessary, but I wanted it perfectly even. The ash looked pretty good, and the ligero point was slightly off center, which is probably why it was burning a little slow on that one side.

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro in the second third with about an inch of gray ash and a burn line running slightly slower on one side, band still on
Halfway through the second third. One side a little slow, not racing.

The draw had opened up a little more by then, to almost perfect.

And if it's possible, the flavor had gotten richer and more decadent. On a single draw it was delicious chocolate, more of a milk chocolate now than a rich dark chocolate. The red pepper was basically gone on a single draw. Cream in the background, some leather, a little bit of coffee. Really good.

A double draw was closer to what it had been before: rich dark chocolate, a little of that red pepper spice, a touch of minerality, and then the fudgy chocolate comes back in, with some leather, some cream, and a little coffee.

The retrohale was so delicious. Crazy rich, fudgy chocolate, like a semi-sweet chocolate, with some cream, some coffee, and a little bit of leather. This is dessert in a cigar.

For me, the single draw and the retrohale are where this thing shines. The double draw is good. The single draw and the retro are just phenomenal.

The ash was pretty tight. Both times I'd knocked it off, it dropped into the ashtray and held together. There were a couple of flyers here and there. It's not stacking, it's just tight. A good-looking ash. Smoke production was good, about average or maybe slightly above, and the smoke texture had been creamy the entire time.

At the end of the second third the burn line was basically razor sharp, with a tight ash and no flakiness on that one. It had around an inch of ash on it, so I let it keep riding for a bit.

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro at the end of the second third with about an inch of tight gray ash and an even burn line, held in front of a stone fireplace
End of the second third. Basically razor sharp, about an inch of ash, no flakiness.

A single draw there had a little more red pepper flavor, not spice, and a little bit of minerality. The chocolate was more of a dark chocolate... not bitter, but less sweet... with some leather and coffee. A double draw was the same profile, but on the finish there was a touch of bitterness and a very, very light earthiness. On a deep retrohale: a very mild red pepper spice, that rich, fudgy, dark chocolate, some leather, light cream, and light coffee. The finish is very chocolatey.

Strength-wise, it really hadn't built at all. I'd put it somewhere in mild to medium, probably slightly closer to medium, but definitely not a full medium.

Final Third

I ashed it going into the final third, and with the cherry not protected anymore, I looked it over to make sure it was burning even all the way around. I wasn't sure I needed to, but this thing was so good that I didn't want to lose a bit of the flavor. It didn't need a touch-up.

The first draw after ashing was rich dark chocolate, some minerality, leather, coffee, and a tiny bit of earthiness in the background. A double draw put the red pepper and minerality on the front, then some chocolate, more of a semi-sweet chocolate, then some coffee and a little leather. On the retrohale the red pepper was a little bit stronger, with a little more spice than there had been, and it was still incredibly comfortable to retrohale. Super sweet, delicious semi-sweet chocolate that just keeps building into that rich, fudgy chocolate. The finish is a little cream, a little leather, a little coffee, and even then the primary note is still chocolate.

It must be that this cigar likes its ash on. Once there was a little more ash built up, that minerality dropped out completely, and the semi-sweet chocolate fudginess came roaring back to the front. That was pretty consistent the whole cigar. Each time I ashed it I'd get some minerality until a little ash built back up, and then the minerality would drop away. The minerality wasn't bad. It's just better without it.

The band came off completely clean, with no issues at all. It was glued pretty well to itself, but only to itself, and not at all to the wrapper.

Final third of the Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro with the band removed, a tight light gray ash and a straight burn line, held in front of a stone fireplace
Band off, final third.

Then I went quiet for a long stretch, mostly because I was enjoying it. I was purposely slowing down to try to make it last longer, which is saying something for a cigar that had already lasted as long as this one had. The draw was fantastic through that whole stretch, and the burn was great.

It was so good that I wanted a longer one. So I went online while I was smoking and found the Masterpiece, the longer vitola, in stock in a ten-count box, and bought a box. That's a cigar you're going to have to set some serious time aside for, and I'll review it separately at some point.

With maybe half an inch of smokeable cigar left, a single draw was dark chocolate, coffee, and a touch of earthiness. A double draw was dark chocolate, a touch of earthiness, a decently strong coffee, and then a light leather. The retrohale was rich dark chocolate with some red pepper spice, very, very mild. It wasn't quite fudgy chocolate anymore after the red pepper, but it was a very rich dark chocolate, then coffee, a little bit of cream, and maybe a touch of leather.

Smoke production was really good by then, well above average for the final third.

I had maybe half a dozen to ten sips of water the entire cigar. There's very, very little bitterness on this thing. A couple of times I picked up an earthy kind of bitterness, but it doesn't linger and it doesn't burn your palate out. Strength at the end was maybe medium, and I hadn't eaten anything in four-plus hours at that point. This is not a cigar you need to worry about beating you over the head with strength, by any stretch of the imagination.

With less than an inch of unburned cigar left, a single draw had no heat at all on my lips, and smoke production was excellent. Holding the wrapper just behind the burn line was slightly uncomfortable, but I could have held it there as long as I wanted. Great job on the construction of this one. Then I laid it down.

Stone ashtray holding the finished nub of the Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro and several intact chunks of gray ash, with the removed band standing beside it
Where I laid it down.

Construction

  • Wrapper: very dark brown, slightly splotchy, rustic looking, and toothier than I thought at first glance. Double cap from what I could see, and a tapered foot.
  • Draw: very tight on the cold draw, which you'd expect on a basically closed foot. A touch tighter than I wanted through the first third, though I never grabbed the draw tool. Almost perfect by the middle of the second third, and fantastic in the final third.
  • Burn: two touch-ups, both small. One after I knocked off the tapered tip, which I do on every tapered foot, and one halfway through the second third when one side ran a little slow. Neither was really necessary. Basically razor sharp at the end of the second third and great through the final third.
  • Ash: tight, with a couple of flyers. Not stacking, just tight. It dropped into the ashtray and held together. Around an inch on it at the end of the second third with no flakiness. Each ash brought some minerality until a little ash built back up.
  • Smoke output: about average, maybe slightly above, through the first two thirds, and well above average in the final third. Creamy texture the entire time.
  • Band: came off completely clean. Glued well to itself and not at all to the wrapper.

Bottom Line

This is definitely a dessert cigar. It's super rich and decadent the whole way through, even into and through the final third. The chocolate is the whole story... rich dark chocolate at the light, fudgy on the retrohale, a little milk chocolate and semi-sweet in the middle, dark again at the end... with a red pepper flavor that's almost all flavor and very little spice, and leather, coffee, and cream behind it. Each ash brought a little minerality that went away once the ash built back up. There was very, very little bitterness, and the strength never got past about medium on a day when I hadn't eaten in hours.

It's a long cigar, and I was not bored with it at all. I was slowing down to make it last.

Would I smoke it again? Five-Pack (3/4). A five-pack of these at a hundred bucks, give or take, I'd do in a heartbeat. A box is a different question. Twenty-five is a ton of cigars, and at more than $500 I wouldn't spend that much money on it today. It's a good cigar, but I'd go buy the Añejo first. The Añejo is a more complex cigar and it changes throughout. This one is just delicious, but it's basically the same profile start to finish. I'm very happy with that profile. It's just not where the box money goes first.

And yes, I bought a box while I was smoking it. That was the Masterpiece, the 9 inch one, which is even longer, and it comes in a box of ten, not twenty-five. They aren't available all the time, they were in stock, and they were on sale at about $18.40 a stick, about $21 a stick with shipping and tax. A sale is not how I judge a cigar. If those hadn't been in stock, I wouldn't have bought a box of the Untold Story at street.

Best for: an afternoon when you've got the better part of two hours and want dessert. Anybody chasing chocolate. It's an easy cigar to retrohale, and it never got past medium on me with nothing in my stomach for four-plus hours. Keep some water nearby and leave the ash on it.


My scale, one question only... would I spend my own money on this again? 4 Box Buy (box on hand, always) / 3 Five-Pack (yes, a few live in the humidor) / 2 Hand-Me-One (wouldn't buy it, wouldn't turn one down) / 1 Not Even Free (I'd rather smoke nothing).

More reviews

Unlit My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto held in hand against a stone wall, medium brown wrapper, cream and gold My Father main band, red and gold La Gran Oferta secondary band, and a teal ribbon foot band
Five-Pack · 3/4$8.50 streetStrength: Mild-Medium

My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto Review

The My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $8.50 street... vanilla and honey from the light to the nub on a smooth...

2026-11-12

Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro held in hand against a stone wall, a dark brown veiny wrapper under the maroon and gold primary band and the secondary band
Hand-Me-One · 2/4$12 streetStrength: Medium

Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro Review

The Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro is a Hand-Me-One (2/4) at about $12 street... a mild, pleasant sweet cream, leather and nuttiness smoke...

2026-11-08

Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro box-pressed robusto held in hand before lighting, dark rustic maduro wrapper with the Family Reserve 1964 band and the 50 Years 2014 band
Box Buy · 4/4$30.40 streetStrength: Medium

Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro Review

The Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro is a Box Buy (4/4) at about $30 street... vanilla, cream, leather and coffee from the first puff to a nub I...

2026-11-01