Guides ›
GuideCigars for a Cold Deck
A cold-deck cigar has four jobs: finish before your hands give up, burn without asking for the lighter every ten minutes, bring enough flavor that you aren't hunting for it under a coat collar, and cost little enough that leaving half of it in the ashtray doesn't sting. Every pick below comes from a full review on this site.
This page is the shopping list. The technique... letting a cigar warm up before you cut it, keeping butane in an inside pocket, getting cigars back into the humidor without condensation... lives on smoking a cigar in cold weather, and I won't repeat it here.
One thing to know about how this list was built. The coolest night written into any review's Setup so far is 64 degrees, feels like 58, with a breeze. So nothing here is a winter report. The picks come from what the reviews actually logged: how long the cigar took, how many touch-ups and relights it needed, how the draw behaved, and what it cost. Cold air makes every one of those matter more. When winter reviews land, this list gets checked against them.
Size down, and know the clock
Which size, when puts a robusto at about an hour and a toro at 90 minutes to two hours, and the toros on this shelf bear that out: the quickest one smoked to the nub with a logged time took about an hour and twenty-five minutes, and plenty ran close to two hours. On a cold night that's the difference between finishing a cigar and abandoning one. If the window is short, go short.
The short ones
The only robusto on this site I'd spend my own money on again that's still in production:
Asylum 13 Corojo Robusto Review
The Asylum 13 Corojo Robusto is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $10 street... a mild-to-medium creamy-bread smoke that flipped my "Asylum is a gimmick...
Zero touch-ups start to finish. Every time the burn wandered, I rotated the slow side down and it fixed itself, which is exactly the behavior you want when the coal is losing heat to cold air. Three things to know: it's the mildest cigar on this list, mostly creamy bread and a light sweetness; the draw ran tight the whole way; and the cap cracked when I clipped it, with no glue on me. File that last one away for the gear section.
And the one cigar here I wouldn't buy for myself:
Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story Review
The Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story is a Hand-Me-One (2/4) at about $8 street... construction and draw as good as I've had in a short cigar...
It's on the list anyway because nothing else on this site pairs a 50-minute smoke with construction this good. One touch-up while the point caught, which comes with any figurado, then a razor-sharp burn, an excellent draw, and no relights. What kept it off my shelf is flavor: dusty, leathery, mineral, with very little sweetness, and sweetness is what I'm usually chasing. If leather and minerality are your lane, this is as well built a short cigar as I've had, on a night when the cold sets the clock.
The toros worth the cold
The cheap one, and the closest thing to a cool-night smoke in any review here:
Diesel Uncaged Toro Review
The Diesel Uncaged Toro is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $6.89 street... a near-perfect draw, big creamy smoke, and a sweet cream retrohale that kept...
64 degrees, feels like 58, a breeze the deck mostly blocked... though I had a fire going, so it was warmer where I sat than the numbers say. About an hour and twenty-five minutes, the quickest finished toro with a logged time on this site. A nearly perfect draw start to finish, two touch-ups, both right after an ash, and no relights. And at under seven dollars, if the wind wins at the halfway mark, you set it down without a second thought. Single draws and the retrohale are where the sweet cream lives, and the last half inch went to earth and leather, which makes it a natural place to call it anyway.
The sweet one:
Perdomo Double Aged 12 Year Vintage Maduro Epicure Review
The Perdomo Double Aged 12 Year Vintage Maduro Epicure is a Box Buy (4/4) at about $12.50 street... I'd spend my own money on this again, no hesitation.
Chocolate, sweetness, and a nuttiness that keeps creeping up through the thirds... the kind of profile you don't have to go looking for. The construction backed it up: a draw I called absolutely perfect, a wrapper with zero cracking, and three touch-ups that were minor corrections, not rescues. I smoked it down by the creek with a little breeze, and the burn never went wonky. The review budgets about 90 minutes for it.
And the long-night pick, for the evening with a fire going and nowhere to be:
Foundation The Tabernacle Havana Seed CT No. 142 Toro Review
The Foundation Tabernacle Havana Seed CT No. 142 Toro is a Box Buy (4/4) at $14.50 to $15.50 street... an easy, easy Box Buy, and the next order will...
An hour and forty-five minutes with zero touch-ups... rotation alone kept the burn even... and a draw I wrote down as perfect. Baking spice, milk chocolate turning to dark, almond, leather, dark coffee, building from medium-plus to full. One caveat that matters more outside in winter: near the end it went out on me, and the only cause I could figure was talking too long between puffs. A cold coal gives you less grace on that than a warm one does, and relighting covers the fix. Talk between puffs, not instead of them.
The gear that earns a coat pocket
Wind is worse than cold, and this is the lighter with wind on its record:
Guevara Lux Single-Flame Lighter Review (1121D)
The Guevara Lux single-flame lighter is a Buy Again at about $20 street... in a heartbeat, and I'm probably buying its double-jet brother next.
It has never misfired on me, wind included. The wide top lips hold a resting cigar in a breeze, and the weight keeps both from going anywhere, which matters on a deck table. It's a single jet, so a 54 or 56 ring takes a little longer to toast. Whatever lighter you carry, keep it in an inside pocket until you need it... the cold-weather page explains why butane quits in the cold, and refill and bleed is worth doing before the season, not during it.
Dry winter air is when wrappers split, and ten dollars of glue turns a crack into a five-minute pause instead of a lost cigar:
PerfecRepair Cigar Glue Review
PerfecRepair cigar glue is a Buy Again at $10 street... it's ten bucks, it saves cigars, and one bottle lasts basically forever.
Two things from the review: shake it first, and give it about five minutes to set before you puff. The Asylum above cracked at the cap with no glue on hand. The Mil Días Sublime cracked twice in one smoke, and the glue held both. Keep it in the same pocket as the lighter. The field repairs page covers the rest.
What stays inside until spring
Some of the best cigars on this site are the wrong cigar for a cold night. The Foundation 10 Year Aniversario Salomon is a 7 x 58 that took just over an hour and fifty minutes, at about $35. The Padrón Family Reserve No. 45 ran the better part of two hours at about $32. Both deserve a chair you won't be leaving early. And a cigar that kept going out on a warm night has nothing in its favor once the coal is fighting cold air: the AJ Fernandez New World Gobernador needed three relights on a 76-degree night. Good cigar, wrong season.
Everything that happens after you pick the cigar is on smoking a cigar in cold weather. Read it before the first frost.
More guides
Best Cigars Under $10 I've Actually Smoked
The under-$10 list as it actually stands: what earned a verdict at street price, what's merely fine, and why it's short right now.
The First Five Cigars
Five cigars in a deliberate order, all of them reviewed here. A forgiving start, a step up each time, and a benchmark to measure everything else against.
Cigars for a Round of Golf
What actually belongs in a golf bag: cigars sized to nine or eighteen holes, priced so a cart ride can't hurt you, picked from real reviews on this site.