Learn ›
Learn · Smoking BasicsAre Cedar Spills Bad for Lighting a Cigar?
A cedar spill is a burning strip of wood, so it does put wood smoke and soot near the foot... that part is chemistry, not opinion. Whether you can taste it in the cigar is a separate question, and nobody has tested it. Used well, the risk is small. Used badly, it's the same mistake as toasting on a fresh sulfur match.
The basic method sits on how to light a cigar. This page takes the one claim that page leaves open: that the spill isn't the clean, flavor-neutral light it's sold as.
What a spill is
A cedar spill is a thin strip of Spanish cedar, often torn from the sheet packed inside a cigar box, lit from another flame and used to toast the foot. The idea is older than cigar lighters. Before friction matches got cheap in the late 1800s, spills of twisted paper, reed, or wood shavings carried fire from the hearth to pipes, candles, and stoves, and Victorian mantels kept them handy in spill vases. The cigar version survived as a ritual for nights with no hurry.
What actually burns
Wood doesn't burn directly. Heat breaks it down first. Water leaves early; above roughly 200°C the wood's polymers start coming apart, hemicellulose first, then cellulose between about 240 and 350°C and lignin between about 280 and 500°C. Some of the gases they release ignite and become the visible flame. Some escape unburned and condense as smoke. What's left chars and glows as an ember.
That smoke belongs to the same family of compounds that flavors smoked food. Burning lignin gives off phenols such as guaiacol and syringol, the molecules most responsible for a "smoky" taste and smell, while cellulose breaks down into sweeter, caramel-type compounds. Spanish cedar (Cedrela odorata) brings its own aromatic oils as well; studies of its bark and stem oils find them dominated by sesquiterpenes such as β-caryophyllene, though the heartwood spills are cut from has been studied far less. So a cedar flame carries more than heat. That much is established.
Soot is a yellow-flame problem
A flame glows yellow because of soot... very fine carbon particles heated until they shine. Give the fuel enough air before it burns and the flame turns blue, with essentially no soot or carbon monoxide. That splits the lighting options cleanly:
- Torch lighters mix butane with air before it burns and run a blue flame. Of everything on this list, the least soot. The two single-jet torches reviewed here, the Guevara Lux and the Jetline Rubanno, both earned a Buy Again.
- Soft-flame lighters, matches, candles, and spills all burn yellow, which means all of them carry soot in the flame.
So "a spill is sooty" is true, and it's equally true of the soft flame many smokers treat as the gentle option. The fix is the one toasting already asks for: hold the flame off the leaf, so the foot gets heat rather than a coat of whatever the flame is carrying.
Does it flavor the cigar?
Here's where the evidence runs out. The big cigar magazine says a spill "imparts a nice little cedar flavor." One accessory reviewer found a slight cedar note that never overpowered the blend. A forum poster who has lit with cedar, matches, and butane reported no difference at all, except that fluid lighters tasted like fluid. The claim that a spill smokes up the foot is the mirror image of the claim that it sweetens it, and no blind or controlled test of either turned up in the research for this page.
One piece of food science points toward a small effect, though it isn't proof. Smoke flavor forms best when wood smolders, around 300 to 400°C, and hotter open flames break those flavor compounds down further. A spill doing its job is mostly open flame. The moment that best fits the folklore is the end of a spill's life, when it stops flaming and starts smoking. That moment is easy to avoid.
Where that leaves it:
- Established: a spill flame carries wood-combustion products and soot, and a match carries sulfur until its head burns off.
- Unsettled: whether either the cedar or the smoke is tasteable in the finished cigar. Both the praise and the complaint are reports, not measurements.
- Folklore: that a spill ruins the light, or that it's the only proper way to light a cigar.
Using one well
- Light the spill from a clean source. A butane lighter is simplest. With a match, let the head burn down to bare wood before it touches the spill, for the same sulfur reason as lighting the cigar itself.
- Let the flare settle. A fresh spill flares as it catches. Toast on the steady flame that follows, not the flare.
- Hold it at an angle. About 45 degrees keeps it burning; standing it upright like a candle puts it out.
- Toast without touching. Rotate the foot over the tip of the flame, never in it. Expect one full spill per toast.
- Swap, don't smoke. When a spill drops from flame to smolder, set it down and light a fresh one rather than holding the foot in the smoke.
- Calm air only. A spill has no wind resistance at all. Outdoors in any breeze, it's a torch night.
- Box cedar works. Strips about half an inch wide from the sheet in a cigar box make serviceable spills, and a shop will often hand over spare sheets from empty boxes.
The side-by-side, planned
Torch, soft flame, and spill on the same cigar, smoked side by side, is on the test list here. It needs the soft-flame lighter and the spills first, so it has no date yet. Until it runs, the fair summary: a tradition with real chemistry behind the worry, and no measurement behind either the praise or the complaint.
Keep reading
- How to light a cigar
- Spanish cedar, explained
- Refilling and bleeding a torch lighter
- Relighting and saving a cigar
Sources
- Hasburgh, L. E., Stone, D. S., Zelinka, S. L., and Plaza, N. Z. (2020). "Characterization of Wood Chemical Changes Caused by Pyrolysis During Flaming Combustion Using X-Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy." In WFS 2020: Wood and Fire Safety, pp. 22–27. Springer. Temperature ranges for hemicellulose, cellulose, and lignin breakdown. research.fs.usda.gov
- Wikipedia. "Pyrolysis." Volatiles igniting as flame, condensing as smoke, and the residue charring to a glowing ember. en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia. "Smoking (cooking)," citing Hui et al., Meat Science and Applications (2001), and McGee, On Food and Cooking (2004). Lignin phenols (guaiacol, syringol), cellulose carbonyls, best smoke flavor at 300 to 400°C smolder. en.wikipedia.org
- Maia, B. H. L. N. S., et al. (2000). "Essential Oils of Toona and Cedrela Species (Meliaceae)." Journal of the Brazilian Chemical Society 11(6): 629–639. Cedrela odorata stem oil led by β-caryophyllene and caryophyllene oxide. embrapa.br
- Eason, H. M., and Setzer, W. N. (2007). "Bark Essential Oil Composition of Cedrela tonduzii." Records of Natural Products 1(2-3): 24–27. Cedrela bark oils dominated by sesquiterpenoids; β-caryophyllene and α-humulene in C. odorata. acgpubs.org
- Wikipedia. "Flame." Yellow from incandescent soot; blue with enough air, no soot or carbon monoxide. en.wikipedia.org
- Wikipedia. "Lighter." Jet lighters burn blue and hotter; standard butane and naphtha flames combust incompletely and burn sooty orange. en.wikipedia.org
- Jefferson Patterson Park and Museum, Maryland. "Curator's Choice: Spill Vase," January 2018. Spills before friction matches, materials, spill vases, decline in the late 19th century. jefpat.maryland.gov
- Cigar Aficionado editors. "How To Light A Cigar With A Cedar Spill," May 14, 2012. Spills from box cedar, half-inch strips, "imparts a nice little cedar flavor." cigaraficionado.com
- Cigar Aficionado editors. "How To Light A Cigar," August 18, 2017. Let the sulfur burn off a match; lighting sources that add odd flavors. cigaraficionado.com
- Nagy, Andrew. "Cigar Reserve Cedar Spills." Cigar Aficionado, August 20, 2014. Toasting by rotating the foot over the flame. cigaraficionado.com
- Blind Man's Puff. "Accessory Review: Cigar Reserve Cedar Spills," February 26, 2015. 45-degree angle, upright to extinguish, a full spill per toast, slight cedar note, not wind-proof. blindmanspuff.com
- Cigar Geeks forum post on lighting methods (undated). No flavor difference between cedar, matches, and butane; fluid lighters the exception. cigargeeks.com