Learn ›

My Cigar Storage Setup

Updated 2026-08-15 · by Eric

A few hundred cigars, zero wooden humidors, and no humidity drama: gasket-sealed plastic totes, a cooler with cedar trays, and two-way packs. The whole system costs less than one decent desktop humidor and holds better numbers.

Why there's no wood in this story

I never bought a wooden humidor and never will... I'd rather spend the money on cigars than on furniture for cigars. Wood looks great and demands maintenance: seasoning, seal checks, seasonal drift. Plastic with a rubber gasket just... seals. My progression was freezer bags, then a humidor bag, then weather-tight food-storage tubs, and every step was cheaper and more stable than the traditional advice. If you're at the start of that road, your first humidor makes the same case from scratch.

The units

The grab-and-go tubs. Weather-tight plastic containers with gasket lids. Two hold my everyday singles and five-packs... one for Connecticut-shade cigars, one for everything darker, sun grown through oscuro... and two are the guest humidor, flavored and infused only, quarantined for ghosting reasons. One thing I don't love about small tubs: the humidity pack ends up in direct contact with cigars, which can leave contact marks. Fixable with a tray or a bigger box... which is half of why the next two units exist.

The cooler. A 450-count cooler-style humidor with three cedar shelf trays holds the bulk of the collection... it cost less than a mid-shelf box of cigars and out-seals every wooden humidor I've ever checked on. Coolers are the best storage deal in the hobby: gasket seal, big capacity, and the cedar trays give you the one thing wood is actually good for... organization and a little aroma... without trusting wood to hold your seal.

The box tote. Newest addition: a roughly 13-gallon gasket tote (rated water-tight) that holds whole boxes, so the cooler stops doubling as a warehouse. Boxes stay shut... cedar boxes breathe through their seams, and propping lids open just wastes space and warps lids. Packs lie loose on top of the closed boxes, not inside them; the tote's air does the equalizing.

The travel bag. A humidor bag with its own pack that never gets unpacked between trips. It lives in a drawer, loaded.

The rules that keep it boring

• Two-way packs everywhere, all at 69 percent. I ran 65 briefly and came back; 69 is the house number until I get around to a proper side-by-side humidity test. Packs get replaced when they go crunchy... never re-wetted. I re-wetted packs early on. It worked until it didn't, and "almost lost a batch" is all the education anyone needs.
• One seasoning warning: high-RH seasoning packs are for wooden humidors. There's nothing to season in plastic... a seasoning pack in a tote just means soggy cigars and a mold gamble. (What RH actually does covers the numbers.)
• No pack touches a bare wrapper for weeks on end. Trays, box lids, or the cardboard-sleeved larger packs.
• A calibrated hygrometer per unit, salt-tested or kit-tested. An uncalibrated hygrometer is worse than none... it's confidence with no data.
• Rest incoming cigars two or three weeks before smoking or judging them. Mail-order cigars arrive travel-shocked.

Temperature is the actual risk

Humidity gets all the attention; temperature is what can genuinely wreck a collection, especially in the South. Tobacco beetle eggs hatch when storage runs warm... low-to-mid 70s Fahrenheit is the commonly cited trigger zone... and a sealed tote in a hot closet is an incubator with a gasket. Every unit I own lives in conditioned interior space that stays below 70°F, away from exterior walls and sun. Not the garage, not the attic. Cool room first, then worry about the decimal point on your RH.

That's the entire system. Nothing on this list needs polishing, seasoning, or believing in. It just needs a cool room, fresh packs on schedule, and the discipline to keep the flavored stuff in its own sealed world.

Keep reading

• Your first humidor
• Two-way humidity packs
• Humidity and RH explained
• Tobacco beetles and freezing

Reviewed at WSA since this page was written