Learn ›
Learn · Smoking BasicsWhat a Local Cigar Shop Is For
A brick-and-mortar's markup isn't buying you the cigar... you can get the cigar cheaper online. It's buying you a person who learns your palate, a phone call when the good stuff lands, and a local business that's still there next year. Whether that's worth it depends entirely on the shop.
My situation, so you can weigh the bias
I don't have a local shop, not really. The two nearest me are each about 45 minutes away, in opposite directions... 90 minutes round trip to buy something the internet delivers to my porch. I still drive it, on purpose, and I still buy there. What follows is why that math works for me, and where it wouldn't.
What the markup buys when the shop is good
A palate on file. Both of my shops have good tobacconists. I can walk in and say what's been hitting for me and what's come off bitter lately, and they'll steer me toward what fits and away from what doesn't. That loop only works if you hold up your end... vague input gets vague output, which is half the argument for keeping a cigar journal. An algorithm shows you what people bought. A good tobacconist tells you what someone with your palate should try, and the difference costs a couple dollars a stick.
The phone call. One of my shops gives me a heads-up when specials are coming, lets me buy over the phone, and holds the box as long as it takes me to get down there. No website does that. For anything allocated or short-supply, a relationship with a shop is the entire game... the good stuff is gone before the general public hears about it.
The local-economy piece. I'd rather pay a little more and have the money stay with a small business in my area than shave a few percent sending it across the country. That's a personal values call, not a cigar argument. I'm putting it on the table because it's a full third of my reason.
What the markup does not buy
A halo. The counter is where I got my worst first-year advice... I said "I'm new," and got steered into a one-wrapper rut that took a year to climb out of (the full story is in first-year mistakes). A markup doesn't make advice good. Some tobacconists know their inventory cold and know palates even better; some are pushing what came in Tuesday, what's overstocked, or what's most expensive. You find out which kind you've got the same way you find out anything: give them specifics, watch what comes back, and check it against your own notes.
The test is simple. A good tobacconist asks you questions before recommending. A bad one starts with the answer.
When online wins, and it often does
Say the quiet part: for pure price on cigars you already know you like, online wins, usually by a lot. Restocking a proven box, catching a real sale, buying singles of something no local shop stocks... that's what the internet is for, and pretending otherwise is the kind of thing this site exists to not do. When a sale changes the math covers how we think about deal prices around here.
The split that's worked for me: discovery and relationships at the shop, restocking online. The shop earns the markup on cigars I haven't smoked yet, because that's where a human doing the picking beats a search box. Once my notes say a cigar is a keeper, the reorder goes wherever the price is right... and a good shop knows that's the deal and keeps your business anyway, on the strength of the next discovery.
If you're 45 minutes out like me
Batch the trip. I go with a list of what I'm curious about, buy across several lines instead of deep in one, and treat the drive as part of a day that was headed that direction anyway. And when the shop calls about something limited, the answer is yes before the details... that phone call is the whole membership fee paying out.