Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro Review
Filed under: Burn Issues · Cigar Bands · Corojo · Fixing a Wavy Burn · Ligero / Seco / Viso · Nicaragua · One Draw or Two · Relighting · Retrohale · Strength vs Body · The Draw · Puro
Verdict: The Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro is a Hand-Me-One (2/4) at about $12 street... a mild, pleasant sweet cream, leather and nuttiness smoke with no real bitterness, trapped inside a roll that burned to one side all night and took four touch-ups and a relight before I put it down. If this one had been rolled better, I could see it being a much better cigar than the one I smoked.
- Brand
- Aganorsa Leaf
- Line
- Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo
- Vitola
- Toro
- Size
- 6 x 54
- Wrapper
- Nicaraguan Corojo (Jalapa)
- Binder
- Nicaraguan Criollo 98 (double binder)
- Filler
- Nicaraguan Criollo 98 and Corojo 99
- Made in
- Nicaragua
- Factory
- Tabacos Valle de Jalapa S.A. (TABSA), Estelí
- Strength
- Mild to medium, building to close to full by the end
- Street price
- $12

Rare Leaf Reserve is Aganorsa Leaf's regular-production line built from low-yield tobaccos off the company's own farms, sold only through its Aganorsa Leaf Select retail partners. It's a Nicaraguan puro rolled at TABSA in Estelí. This is my first Aganorsa Leaf cigar of any kind, so I came in with no history on the brand either way.
The Setup
- Cigar: Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo, Toro, 6 x 54. Nicaraguan Corojo wrapper grown in Jalapa over a double binder of Nicaraguan Criollo 98, with Criollo 98 and Corojo 99 filler. A Nicaraguan puro made at Tabacos Valle de Jalapa S.A. (TABSA) in Estelí.
- Street price: about $12 a single online. Neptune lists the single at $12.00 and Atlantic at $11.97, Famous sells it by the five-pack at $13.30 a stick before their sale price, and the box of 15 runs about $180 against a $199.50 MSRP. It's a select-retailer line, so not every shop carries it.
- What I paid: $9.96. One single, ordered online September 22, $12 less a 17% coupon. My own money.
- Storage: the main humidor, the Herf-a-Dor, at 69% RH since it arrived September 25, so about six weeks of rest.
- When/where: lit at about 3:30 in the afternoon on the back deck. 61°, feels like 62, 43% humidity, a light breeze I was mostly protected from, and a fire going in the fireplace, so it felt warmer than the number.
- Smoke time: about an hour and forty minutes. I laid it down around 5:10 with about an inch left.
- Food beforehand: chicken kebabs and a little steak with a San Pellegrino about two and a half hours before, and three water crackers about twenty minutes before lighting.
- First cigar of the day, paired with water. Cut with the Xikar XO straight cutter, clean.
Light Up and First Third
A pretty clean-looking wrapper, decently veiny, with a very clean double cap. The cut was clean and the cold draw was great: very mild, a light sweetness. If you licked your lips you got a tingle, it was pretty spicy on the lips and tongue, and a retrohale on the cold draw tingled my sinuses.
It was very bready on the toast and light. Once it was lit, a single draw gave me a little red pepper spice, slightly bready, a little leather, and a touch of cream. Good. A double draw put a lot more red pepper on the palate, the breadiness went away, and it was mostly that pepper sitting on my palate with a little leather. The retrohale was a decent amount of white pepper, not blowing my sinuses off but pretty prominent, then mostly leather with a touch of cream sitting on the palate.
During the toast and light, the cap stuck to my lip and half of it came off. Just the one half, so it looks like that half wasn't glued on well. It never affected anything, never started to unwrap, never cracked.
I could tell there was a decent amount of breadiness and creamy leather in the background, but even on regular draws, blowing it out of my mouth, that red pepper sat all over my tongue and palate and covered the rest. The smoke texture was creamy and smoke production was good.
About twenty minutes in it was burning pretty crooked, a quarter inch or more from one side to the other, and it kept going until the far side was somewhere between three quarters of an inch and an inch ahead. The flavor wasn't bad. It was pretty enjoyable. The red pepper wasn't strong, it was just overpowering the rest of the flavors, and you could tell there was more the cigar wanted to give. I knocked the ash off and touched it up as close to even as I could.
After that first touch-up the smoke went strange: very thin on a single draw, light on a double, above average on a triple, so I needed two draws to get close to normal smoke. It wasn't doing that before the touch-up. The red pepper did die way down, though. A single draw was a light red pepper you felt around your tongue, a little nuttiness, and some leather. A double draw was some red pepper, leather, and light earthiness. The retrohale turned into pretty strong to very strong white pepper, stinging my sinuses and making my eyes water, then leather, light cream, and that earthiness.
By the end of the first third the smoke production was back where it started. The burn was still crooked. I'd had the slow side rotated to the bottom almost since light up, when it first started going crooked, and it stayed consistently slow on that side. When I ashed it, it broke straight across on the crooked burn line, so I couldn't tell where the ligero was. My guess was it was pushed to one side, or the cigar was rolled tighter on that side.
Second Third

Into the second third I had close to three quarters of an inch from the fastest-burning side to the slowest, so I ashed it. The red pepper was mostly gone. It took three draws to get good smoke production, and the flavor was very, very mild: light leather and not much else.
When I ashed it there was something like a hole in the center of the foot, and there was no point anywhere, just the sides that weren't burning properly. It's not that it was bad. I just hate burning a ton of tobacco off to get a cigar anywhere close to even, and I don't mind using a torch for a touch-up, but this was a lot. That was the second touch-up.

Right after the touch-up there was a little red pepper, very mild but still there, a little nuttiness, and a very light breadiness that came and went quick. The finish was basically nothing, no flavor of any kind lingering after the draw. The retrohale was pretty strong, I'd say very strong, white pepper, burning my sinuses and making my eyes water, and not an initial burn that's then gone. It stayed. Once it settled, there was some nice light leather and a light sweet cream that just sat on the palate.
The smoke production was weird. Sometimes it was really thin on the first draw or two, and sometimes it was really good, even on a single draw. I wasn't doing anything else and I wasn't forgetting to draw on it. When the smoke was good, though, the flavor was decent: mostly leather, light cream, and some nuttiness. None of the flavors were super pronounced, but you didn't have to search for them either. A single draw was cream, nuttiness, and leather, then it finished and left nothing behind. A double draw added more red pepper, not strong, just something you felt on the palate, with leather, a little nuttiness, and a little cream. I wasn't getting any coffee on it, which surprised me, because I usually get coffee and leather together.
The secondary band came off completely clean. It was glued well to itself and only to itself.
On a retrohale of maybe a quarter of the draw, you still got the white pepper but without the burning, stinging sensation of a bigger retro, and outside of that clean white pepper it was light cream and light leather. Then I took a sip of water, took a draw, and got a good amount of cream. Mild in flavor, but a very noticeable sweet cream was the primary note. At that point it was very good. Good sweet cream, light leather, not much else.

The burn line was already going wavy from where I touched it up, and then it was running ahead on one side again. It was burning quick on one side and slow on the other three, and the fast side was where that hole was. If this was rolled better, I could see it being much better than what it was. It wasn't bad, and it wasn't crazy earthy. Every once in a while there was a wet leaf flavor that came and went quick. Strength was somewhere between mild and medium, probably medium at that point.
I'd normally keep a cigar burning even, but this one was so uneven that I let it run for a while. Otherwise I'd have been burning so much of the leaf off. Then the smoke went very thin again, and I think I figured out what was going on: a gap in the roll where that hole was. Most of the draw was going through that spot, so it burned fast on that side, and everything else was nearly going out between draws even though I was only waiting about thirty seconds. By then I was at the end of the second third on one side and about halfway through it on the other.

After ashing it, it looked less like a hole and more like the concentrated center was sitting on the far side, with most of the draw going through the looser side. I burned at least half an inch off the rest of the cigar to get it anywhere close to even. That was the third touch-up, and it meant whatever the smoke time was going to be, it would be way quicker than it should be.
Final Third
At the start of the final third, after getting it even again, smoke production was good. The draw was still good, maybe a touch snug from about the second third on, but good. A single draw gave light earthiness and some leather. A double draw was more earthiness and some light leather. The smoke texture was creamy, but there was no cream in the flavor and no sweetness at that point. The retrohale, which I only took a little of, was still very strong white pepper that lingered and kept burning my sinuses, with a very light cream and leather behind it.
Even with a good amount of cigar left, I got a little heat on my tongue from one draw. The primary band came off clean, glued well to itself and not to the wrapper at all. A double draw had a little nuttiness and a tiny bit of cream with the earth and leather, and for a minute that fast side wasn't racing ahead. I hoped whatever roll issue it had was done. I wasn't holding my breath.
About ten minutes later the burn was going crooked again, across about half the cigar this time instead of just that one side. There was some dustiness, a little wet leaf, a little nuttiness, and light earthiness. The retrohale was still strong white pepper with very light cream, some leather, and some earthiness.

I spoke too soon. Same thing as before: burning fast on the one side, over half an inch from one side to the other, the other side basically not burning from where I'd touched it up, and super thin smoke again. I knocked the ash off. It wasn't a hole running straight through. It looked like it was just rolled tight to the one side. There wasn't a single point on it the entire time.

So I burned more tobacco off to get it even for the last half of the final third. That was the fourth touch-up. Touching it up this much was annoying, but what frustrated me most was that it's not a bad cigar. It has decent flavor, mild flavor, but the burn was so bad that I know it wasn't giving me what it was meant to give.
Right after that touch-up there was a wet, almost tea leaf note, a little nuttiness, and a little light earth and light leather. No heat on my lips or tongue right then, and good smoke production. I couldn't say much about the ash, because it never burned straight long enough for me to see how it stacked. Strength had climbed to somewhere between medium and full, and I was starting to feel it. A little heat came back on my tongue on a single draw.

Then it nearly went out on me. By then the wrapper leaf wasn't even burning. It was only burning the center, with at least an eighth of an inch of wrapper standing up all the way around. My guess is a bad roll. I relit it, making sure the wrapper all the way around and the filler were both lit.
By the end it was mostly light earth. Not crazy bitter or anything, but I was getting heat from it, I don't like that, and there was no real flavor left that I was enjoying. It finished close to full strength for me. I was done fighting with it and laid it down with about an inch left.

Construction
- Wrapper: pretty clean, decently veiny, with a very clean double cap. Half of the cap came off when it stuck to my lip during the toast and light. It never unwrapped or cracked.
- Draw: great on the cold draw, good once lit, maybe a touch snug from about the second third on.
- Burn: the problem with this cigar. Crooked within the first twenty minutes and crooked or running to one side for the rest of the night, with no point anywhere. Four touch-ups, about twenty minutes in, early in the second third, at the end of the second third, and halfway through the final third, plus a relight near the end when it nearly went out and only the center was burning. I burned a lot of tobacco off with the torch. My read is a gap or loose spot in the roll that pulled most of the draw to one side.
- Ash: I can't really say. It never burned straight long enough to see how it stacked, and it broke straight across the crooked burn line when I ashed it.
- Smoke output: creamy texture and good production early, then in and out all night. Some stretches took two or three draws to get a normal amount of smoke, and some single draws were great.
- Band: both bands came off completely clean, glued well to themselves and not to the wrapper.
Bottom Line
The flavor was there. Sweet cream, leather, nuttiness, light breadiness early, red pepper on the palate that settled down after the first touch-up, light earth, wet leaf and a little dustiness late, and a white pepper retrohale that ran from prominent to very strong and stayed strong the whole way. Never any real bitterness. When the smoke production was good, the middle of this cigar was very good: a mild, noticeable sweet cream with light leather. None of it was pronounced, but you never had to search for it, and strength built from mild-medium to close to full by the end.
The construction is what sinks it. A crooked burn from the first twenty minutes, four touch-ups and a relight, thin smoke that came and went, the wrapper refusing to burn near the end, and heat in the last stretch, on a cigar that should have had more to give. This may be a one-off. It's my first Aganorsa Leaf cigar ever, and I don't know whether this is normal for them or just a bad stick. But I judge every cigar on the one I smoked, and I'm not going to buy three or four more to find out.
Would I smoke it again? Hand-Me-One (2/4). The flavor is decent and never turned really bitter, which is what keeps it off Not Even Free, but at $12 a stick I'd want a cigar I don't have to babysit with a torch the whole way. I wouldn't buy another one, and I wouldn't turn one down if someone handed it to me.
Best for: someone who likes a mild Nicaraguan puro with sweet cream and leather and doesn't mind a heavy white pepper retrohale. Keep a torch close. If you want a creamy Corojo for less money, the Asylum 13 Corojo Robusto earned a Five-Pack here.
My scale, one question only... would I spend my own money on this again? 4 Box Buy (box on hand, always) / 3 Five-Pack (yes, a few live in the humidor) / 2 Hand-Me-One (wouldn't buy it, wouldn't turn one down) / 1 Not Even Free (I'd rather smoke nothing).
More reviews

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro Review
The Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $21 street... rich, fudgy chocolate from the light to the nub with almost...

My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto Review
The My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $8.50 street... vanilla and honey from the light to the nub on a smooth...

Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro Review
The Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro is a Box Buy (4/4) at about $30 street... vanilla, cream, leather and coffee from the first puff to a nub I...