Are you 21 or older?

This site discusses cigars. You must be of legal smoking age to enter.

Latest review: Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro →
One question. Answered honestly.
Cigar Review

My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto Review

2026-11-12  Five-Pack · 3/4 My Money · by Eric

Filed under: Burn Issues · Cigar Bands · Field Repairs · Ecuador · Tight Draw · Fixing a Wavy Burn · Gauging Strength · Habano · Ligero / Seco / Viso · Nicaragua · One Draw or Two · The Ash · Retrohale · Strength vs Body · The Draw · The Nub

Verdict: The My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $8.50 street... vanilla and honey from the light to the nub on a smooth, mild-to-medium smoke, held out of a box by a snug draw, a burn that needed two touch-ups, and a wrapper that cracked near the end. The flavor was great start to finish. The construction on this one wasn't.

Brand
My Father
Line
La Gran Oferta
Vitola
Robusto
Size
5 x 50
Wrapper
Ecuadorian Habano Rosado
Binder
Nicaraguan
Filler
Nicaraguan
Made in
Nicaragua
Factory
My Father Cigars S.A., Estelí
Strength
Mild building to about medium
Street price
$8.50
Unlit My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto held in hand against a stone wall, medium brown wrapper, cream and gold My Father main band, red and gold La Gran Oferta secondary band, and a teal ribbon foot band
Two bands and a foot band. There's not a lot of wrapper left to look at.

I'd never smoked this one before. I picked it up with a group of other cigars I'd never smoked, just on some recommendations, and this one definitely held true. La Gran Oferta means "the great offering." My Father brought the line out in 2018, with an Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper over Nicaraguan binder and filler, rolled at the My Father factory in Estelí. The listing I pulled up while I was smoking calls it medium to full strength. That's not what I got.

The Setup

  • Cigar: My Father La Gran Oferta, Robusto, 5 x 50. Ecuadorian Habano Rosado wrapper, Nicaraguan binder, Nicaraguan filler. Rolled at My Father Cigars S.A. in Estelí, Nicaragua.
  • Street price: about $8.50 for a single online. Boxes of 20 run about $154 to $160 online, a little under $8 a stick.
  • What I paid: $8.20 for a single, $6.81 after a 17% coupon, ordered online in September. My own money.
  • Storage: my Herf-a-Dor at 69% RH. It went straight in when it arrived, about seven weeks ago.
  • When/where: started at 8:05 on a Thursday night on my back deck. 45°, feels like 41, 76% humidity, with a gentle breeze. I was about to light a fire, so it was going to be warmer than that where I was sitting.
  • Smoke time: a little over an hour before I laid it down.
  • Food beforehand: hibachi steak and lo mein with a San Pellegrino about two hours before, then three water crackers about 20 minutes before I lit it.
  • First cigar of the day, and my first in about four days, paired with water. Cut with the Xikar XO, lit with my Jetline Rubanno single-flame torch.

Light Up and First Third

It's a good-looking cigar, but it's mostly covered. There are two bands that take up a good amount of space, plus a foot band. It looked like there might be a slight tear underneath the primary band, so I got a photo of that to see what it really was. Otherwise it looked good. A nicely packed foot, and a little veiny, though with that much band you can't really see.

Close-up of the My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto wrapper where it meets the top edge of the main band, with a small light-colored spot at the edge of the band
The spot at the edge of the primary band that I thought might be a tear. It wasn't.

It's what I'd consider small, mostly because I smoke toros the vast majority of the time. A 50 ring gauge is on the smaller side of my standard go-to. Generally that's a 52 to a 56.

It has a triple cap. My Father triple caps everything that comes out of its factory, and I like that. On this one I had to make an extra cut, and with those extra caps on there you're less worried about it cracking.

I cut it with the Xikar XO. The cold draw had a nice sweetness, but it was a little bit snug, so I cut a little more off to see if that made a difference. There was a slight tingle in my sinuses when I retrohaled the cold draw, a very nice, mild sweetness coming off of it, and it was decently spicy on my lips. It was still a bit snug, even after the second cut.

On the toast and light, a really nice breadiness and some leather. The first draw had a bit of spice to it, a little pepper that sits on the tip of your palate, leather for sure, a touch of coffee, and a little nuttiness. A double draw was the exact same flavor profile, no difference at all.

The retrohale was a mild white pepper, not overwhelming or overpowering at all. And there was a really nice sweetness through the entire retrohale, even with that white pepper being there. Usually I get the pepper first, whatever pepper it is, and the flavors come in afterwards. Not here. The sweetness was there the entire time, with a little cream and a little leather besides. It was distinct, and it took me a while to put a word to it.

Vanilla. I don't know why it took me so long to place that. Vanilla and a little bit of honey. Very pleasant, very enjoyable. A little later I was getting some baking spice too, which was very nice as well.

Near the end of the first third, it was very good on a single draw: that nice honey, leather, and some coffee. The nuttiness was mostly gone. The retrohale had the honey and a touch of bitterness.

That's also where the burn went off. It had a nice point on it, but one side was racing ahead, and it looked like there was a legitimate hole inside the cigar on that side. Which is weird, because it was packed well. I wouldn't have expected that. There was a little bit of wind, but just a gentle breeze where I was, nothing that would make one side burn substantially faster.

Foot of the My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto seen head-on at the end of the first third, glowing ember with a visible hole running into the filler on one side
End of the first third. That's the hole, on the side that was racing ahead.

I ashed it and touched it up. I didn't try to make it even, because the ligero was burning well and there was such a nice point going. I just made sure the slow side was burning really good. The draw hadn't gotten any worse, and it hadn't gotten any better. Still a touch too snug.

Second Third

At the start of the second third, the vanilla and honey were still very prominent, but just at the beginning of the draw. They fade pretty quick, and then you're left with leather, some woodiness, and a little coffee. No earthiness at all, and not bitter at all. On a double draw, the vanilla and honey dropped way down and leather was the prominent note. Then a nice sweetness came in a little, faded away, and left coffee and a little woodiness.

The retrohale was really nice. Mild white pepper mixed with that honey and vanilla, and the honey and vanilla actually felt more potent now. That hangs on for a while. When it fades, you're left with leather and a little nuttiness. The nuttiness fades relatively quickly, and then it's leather and maybe a touch of cream sitting on your palate.

Smoke production at that point was slightly below average, though it's a very creamy smoke texture. The burn was still crooked, but it looked like it was mostly staying at the same pace.

About halfway through the second third, the strength was mild, maybe mild plus, getting close to a medium. And the burn was starting to correct itself. The ash was pretty tight. Not stacking, just generally pretty tight.

Both bands came off clean. The secondary band was glued well, but only to itself, and it came off with no issues at all. The primary band came off the same way. And that spot I was worried about underneath it turned out to be extra leaf that must have been stuck to the band and gotten glued on. It's not a hole or an imperfection in the wrapper at all, which was nice to see.

Then the flavor profile shifted a bit. It was less sweet for sure. A single draw still gave a little vanilla sweetness, then it went a little bit dusty, then leather, woodiness, and some coffee. It's actually more of a cedar than a generic woodiness. No earth, no bitterness, and still a very creamy cigar. On a double draw, the vanilla and honey came back out, and then leather, nuttiness, some cedar, and coffee. That was different. Usually on a double draw I get less sweetness, not more. The retrohale still had lots of vanilla and honey, some nuttiness, then cream and leather.

It's very good. It's very enjoyable. And I'd only had maybe a sip or two of water, so it's not like I was cleaning my palate off.

My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto in the second third with both bands removed, a pale gray ash and a burn line that is nearly even, held over a deck with a stone ledge behind
Second third. The burn really was correcting itself.

By this point the burn had almost fully corrected itself, and I'd only done the one touch-up, back at the transition from the first third to the second. It looked like that hole was just a gap in the filler. I was really happy it was self-correcting.

So far, it was definitely mild enough that I'd be happy to grab this thing first thing in the morning with a cup of coffee and not worry about it.

Final Third

At the start of the final third, the ash was leaning a little bit to one side, probably because I'd been holding that side down on the ashtray the whole time. I knocked it off. It came off whole, bounced in the ashtray, and stayed clean. There was still a ligero point in the center of this thing, slightly off center. And the hole was still there, so it must not have gone out the side like I thought it did.

My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto at the start of the final third with the ash knocked off, a pointed ember at the foot and a slightly uneven burn line, held between thumb and finger
Start of the final third, ash off. Still a point on it.

It was burning good, but it was a little more than slightly crooked. So I grabbed the lighter and hit just the slowest side, to make sure that was well lit going into the final third, since knocking the ash off took some protection off that ember. That was the second touch-up.

While I was looking up pricing, I saw flavor notes for this cigar that say molasses. I tried to think whether that's what it is and I'm wrong on the honey and vanilla. But to me, it's honey and vanilla. And that sweetness was still there.

A single draw was light vanilla, leather, some nuttiness, a little bit of cedar, a little bit of coffee, and a touch of earth. A double draw was vanilla and honey right away, then cedar, leather, and some coffee. The retrohale was honey, a general woodiness, leather and coffee, and a little bit of earth. It's a very mild earth. It's there, but it's not biting or bitter or anything like that.

That same listing says this is supposed to be a medium to full strength cigar. Maybe it builds a lot at the end, but this was not medium to full by any stretch for what I was feeling.

The draw hadn't changed at all. A little bit snug. I'd like it a little bit more open. But I had my draw tool sitting within a foot of me, and I didn't need it.

A little further in... man, this is really good. I retrohaled basically a full breath, and there's a mild white pepper to it, but that honey and vanilla are still right there, front and center. It fades from the honey and vanilla to some cedar, and then a mix of light cream and leather together. Really good.

Smoke production in the final third was about average. It increased. Before, I was sometimes needing two draws to get good smoke out of it. Now I was getting really good smoke even on a single draw.

Not that it's the thing I judge a cigar on, but I'd only had a couple of sips of water this entire time. Partially that's because it was cold out. A lot of it is because it's such a smooth cigar that I wasn't thinking about taking some water to clean my palate or get rid of some bitterness.

A single draw at that point was vanilla, then cedar, then some of that vanilla sweetness coming back after the cedar before it fades into leather and coffee. The earthiness was pretty much gone. The burn was a bit wavy and crooked. The ash was pretty tight. In the final third I brushed off maybe two flyers, small pieces that stuck out, but otherwise it had been tight the whole time through.

Two thirds of the way through the final third, double draws were still giving vanilla and honey, cedar, leather, coffee, and some light earthiness. And then the wrapper cracked, on the slow side of the cigar. I had glue right there, but I wasn't going to try to glue that. I was getting to the end of the final third, where I'd normally stop anyway. I was going to take this one longer, but not with the crack.

Short remaining piece of the My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto late in the final third with a crack running along the wrapper near the burn line and a pale gray ash, held in fingertips
Late in the final third. The crack, on the slow side.

I kept going to see what would happen when the burn line hit it. I expected the flavor to drop off a cliff, and I expected the draw to open up a lot more, and neither one happened. As it burned into the crack, the wrapper didn't split any more. A single draw was still that nice vanilla, then cedar, leather, coffee, and earth. A double draw had a hint of the vanilla and honey that very quickly faded to cedar, leather, and a light earthiness. Not an earthiness that I mind at all. I did get a little bit of heat on my palate. The retrohale still had that nice vanilla honey, some light cedar, leather, coffee, a touch of cream, and a touch of earthiness, but not one I was upset about.

The only thing the crack appeared to do was slow the bottom burn down even more. The burn line was pretty good except for the very bottom, where there was a small finger of wrapper, and that's a double whammy, because it's where the crack was and it's the slow side of the cigar. My assumption, whether it's right or wrong, is that it's looser there, so the wrapper isn't held as tight to the binder and filler, and it burns slower.

Holding it just behind the burn line, about an eighth of an inch, was very comfortable. You could hold it there all day long. Nice construction there.

At the nub, a single draw was still comfortable, with a nice vanilla before it fades to leather, coffee, and a light earthiness. No bitterness, even still. A double draw definitely had some heat. I retrohaled it one more time: vanilla and honey as the main tone, the cedar gone, some leather and cream mixed together, and a very light earthiness. Once I was getting some warmth even on a single draw, I laid it down. I didn't want any more heat than that.

Wooden ashtray holding the last inch of the My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto with a long pale ash still attached, next to two more pieces of ash
Where I laid it down.

It finished near a medium. I don't know where the medium to full comes from. To me, this was mild to medium the whole smoke. Mild at the beginning, building to around a medium near the final third.

Construction

  • Wrapper: good-looking and a little veiny, with a nicely packed foot and a triple cap, mostly hidden under two bands and a foot band. It cracked on the slow side about two thirds of the way through the final third. I didn't glue it, and it didn't split any more as the burn went through it.
  • Draw: a little snug from the cold draw to the nub, even after a second cut. It never got worse and it never got better. I'd have liked it a little more open, but I never needed the draw tool sitting next to me.
  • Burn: one side raced ahead by the end of the first third, with a hole inside the cigar on that side. It almost fully corrected itself through the second third, then went a bit wavy and crooked again in the final third. Two touch-ups: one at the transition from the first third to the second, and one at the start of the final third.
  • Ash: pretty tight the whole way, not stacking. The ash I knocked off at the start of the final third came off whole, bounced in the ashtray, and stayed clean. Maybe two flyers in the final third. A ligero point in the center.
  • Smoke output: slightly below average through the second third, sometimes needing two draws. About average in the final third, with really good smoke on a single draw. A very creamy texture.
  • Band: both bands came off completely clean, glued well but only to themselves. The spot I thought was a tear under the primary band was extra leaf glued to the band.

Bottom Line

The flavor profile was great, start to finish. Bread and leather at the light, then a vanilla and honey sweetness that showed up early and never left, with leather, coffee, cedar, a little nuttiness, and cream moving around it. The retrohale was really nice all the way through: a mild white pepper with that honey and vanilla front and center. There was a touch of bitterness on one retrohale near the end of the first third and a very mild earth in the final third, and that was it. The strength ran mild to medium, nowhere near the medium to full on the listing. This is one I feel like I could hand to somebody who's a new smoker. They're not going to get overwhelmed with strength on it.

The burn obviously wasn't perfect. It took two touch-ups, and those were really just to get it burning evenly again because of that hole on one side. The draw was a little bit snugger than I wanted it to be. And it cracked at the end, though the crack didn't really affect the flavor at all. If it did, then it would have been even better without it, and that's hard to imagine. If I'd paid fifteen bucks for this cigar, I wouldn't be thrilled with the burn and the draw. Flavor-wise, it'd still be really good.

Would I smoke it again? Five-Pack (3/4). The price point on this thing is great, and at this price, on flavor alone, I'd be very happy with a box of these. But the verdict gets judged on the cigar I smoked, at street price, and this one had a snug draw, a burn issue, two touch-ups, and a crack. That's a five-pack. If I found it on sale for what I paid for it, I wouldn't be upset with a box of these, but that's not how it's judged. I definitely will get some more of these and enjoy them, and I'll probably have to buy one in the Toro, my normal size, too.

Best for: a new smoker, because the strength isn't going to overwhelm anybody. And a morning cigar with a cup of coffee, where a robusto is about the right size for me.


My scale, one question only... would I spend my own money on this again? 4 Box Buy (box on hand, always) / 3 Five-Pack (yes, a few live in the humidor) / 2 Hand-Me-One (wouldn't buy it, wouldn't turn one down) / 1 Not Even Free (I'd rather smoke nothing).

More reviews

Unlit Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro held in hand against a stone wall, very dark brown wrapper, red and gold A. Fuente Gran Reserva band over a black and gold lower band, long perfecto with a tapered foot
Five-Pack · 3/4$21 streetStrength: Mild-Medium

Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro Review

The Arturo Fuente Hemingway Untold Story Maduro is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $21 street... rich, fudgy chocolate from the light to the nub with almost...

2026-11-14

Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro held in hand against a stone wall, a dark brown veiny wrapper under the maroon and gold primary band and the secondary band
Hand-Me-One · 2/4$12 streetStrength: Medium

Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro Review

The Aganorsa Leaf Rare Leaf Reserve Corojo Toro is a Hand-Me-One (2/4) at about $12 street... a mild, pleasant sweet cream, leather and nuttiness smoke...

2026-11-08

Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro box-pressed robusto held in hand before lighting, dark rustic maduro wrapper with the Family Reserve 1964 band and the 50 Years 2014 band
Box Buy · 4/4$30.40 streetStrength: Medium

Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro Review

The Padrón Family Reserve No. 50 Maduro is a Box Buy (4/4) at about $30 street... vanilla, cream, leather and coffee from the first puff to a nub I...

2026-11-01