Guides ›
GuideThe Cutters and Lighters I'd Actually Buy
If you're buying your first setup today: the Vertigo Hawk and whatever it costs to not overthink the cutter yet. If you're upgrading: the Xikar XO and the Guevara Lux. Everything below comes from a full review on this site... no gear appears here that I haven't carried and used.
Gear roundups are usually catalogs... every product gets a blurb, every blurb finds something nice to say, and somehow nothing ever loses. This page works differently. Nine pieces of cutting and lighting gear have been through full reviews here, each one used for months, most bought with my own money. Some won. Some lost. The cards pull live from the reviews, so what you see is the actual verdict, not a rewritten-for-the-roundup version.
Cutters
My daily cutter, and the reason I stopped shopping:
Xikar XO Cutter Review (Gunmetal)
Verdict: Buy Again... it walked in four months ago and retired every other cutter I own. My wife gave me this for my birthday back in March, and I don't think I've cut a single cigar with anything else since... and I've got a half dozen other cutters sitting right there, some che
The V-cut I'd point you at if the V-cut is your thing... with the caveat that I've drifted back to straight cuts myself:
Xikar VX2 V-Cut Cutter Review
Verdict: Buy Again... if the V-cut is your regular cut. It's solid, it's sharp, and I don't believe it's ever cracked a wrapper on me... but I've drifted back to straight cuts, and $50 is hard to justify for a once-in-a-while tool. I bought this because I wanted a proper V-cut, m
And the two that didn't make it. The Xi2 was my first real cutter and it taught me a lot, just not at that price. The Colibri is half a great tool:
Xikar Xi2 Cutter Review (Hero Series)
Verdict: Wouldn't Buy... not at Hero Series money. This was my first real cutter... the first one that wasn't a $5-10 counter grab at the cigar shop... and it taught me a lot, including what sixty dollars should and shouldn't buy. The blades are excellent and Xikar's lifetime war
Colibri SV-Cut Cutter Review (Black & Chrome)
Verdict: Wouldn't Buy Again... half of this cutter is excellent, and the half I'd actually reach for keeps pinching my cigars. The SV-Cut's whole pitch is two cutters in one body: a deep V-cut on one side, a straight cut on the other. The V side has been flawless for ten months.
Lighters
The one I'd hand a beginner first:
Vertigo Hawk Triple Jet Flame Lighter Review
Verdict: Buy Again... and if you're just getting into cigars, this is the one I'd hand you first. I'm pretty sure this is the very first torch lighter I ever bought when I got into cigars, and it lit basically my whole first three or four months, tons of cigars, without ever givi
The one that actually lights most of my cigars... a $20 single jet that has never once failed me:
Guevara Lux Single-Flame Lighter Review (1121D)
Verdict: Buy Again... in a heartbeat, and I'm probably buying its double-jet brother next. Twenty bucks, a year-plus of near-daily duty, roughly 70% of every cigar I've lit... and it has never once failed me. Not after a refill, not in wind, not ever. I bought this expecting a $2
Two more that earned their keep, one practical and one that's just fun to use:
Jetline Rubanno Single-Flame Lighter Review
Verdict: Buy Again... it's a keeper, just not the one my hand grabs first. I bought this because half the cigar reviewers I watch rave about it, and more than one says it's the lighter that lives on their desk. Big tank, a single flame you can dial from tiny to big, solid build f
Jetline Mr. Fatboy Quad Torch Review
Verdict: Buy Again... at full retail, without blinking. And not for the usual reasons. This is not my most practical lighter, it's not my most efficient lighter, and it's terrible at touch-ups. It's a comically oversized quad torch with a flame you can adjust to several inches ta
And the one I'd skip:
Rockwell Quad Torch Lighter Review
Verdict: Wouldn't Buy... and I never have, which is kind of the point. Every one of these I own showed up free... promo throw-ins with five-packs and orders from various cigar companies and dealers. As a freebie, it's a perfectly decent little torch that works every time. As a $2
How to read all this
Two patterns from a year of gear. First, jet count is marketing... I light almost everything with a single flame, and the only thing more jets ever bought me was a button too hot to touch by the end of the light. Second, the price-performance curve flattens fast. The gap between a $10 lighter and a $20 lighter is real. The gap between $20 and $80 is mostly pocket jewelry. Spend the difference on cigars.
If you're starting from zero, the beginner kit page makes the full minimal-spend case, including why you don't need half of what the accessory wall wants to sell you. And if a cut goes wrong anyway, how to cut a cigar covers the recovery.