Guides ›
GuideBuy It on Sale
Every verdict on this site is judged at street price, and the tier never moves for a sale. But a few reviews close with a standing exception: a specific, recurring discount at which the buying answer changes. This is the shoppable version of those notes. Three cigars carry one right now. That's the whole list, on purpose.
The rule is spelled out in how I set street price, and it's short. A cigar that's only worth it on a deal isn't worth it, so the tier is judged at the everyday number. When a real, repeating discount pushes a cigar over a tier line, I say so in the closing prose of the review, and the tier stays put. The tier is the pay-street answer. The exception is the watch-for-a-sale answer. When one of these discounts shows up, it lands on the deals page with a link back to the review, so the price sits next to the verdict instead of floating alone.
The standing exceptions

The Filthy Viking Toro Review (American Viking Cigars)
The Filthy Viking Toro from American Viking is a Five-Pack (3/4) at $11.44 street... with a standing exception you should know about: catch these...
The cleanest example on the shelf, because the verdict names the exception outright. At the single price, no. At full box price, a few live in the humidor. Then the brand runs 20 to 25 percent off boxes about quarterly, which lands a stick right around $8 shipped, and at that number I break my own rule and buy the box without a second thought. That's how I bought mine and how I'll rebuy. A mild, easy, tobacco-sweet coffee cigar with one gear, and at eight dollars that's plenty. The sale is always coming.

Oliva Serie V Toro Review
The Oliva Serie V Toro is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $13 street... a sweet, nutty, medium cigar that punches way above its price tag, and asks for a...
Sweet, almond turning to peanut, a baking spice retrohale you can take in full, and a sweetness that lingers between puffs longer than almost anything I smoked this year. What keeps it off a box at street is a tight draw, a burn that asked for a lighter five or six times, and no act two. The exception: this line shows up on sale and at auction constantly, I paid $5.70 a stick for a box of ten, and at that price it's a box every time. The price is what makes it a box, not the cigar. One catch: the Toro isn't in the current lineup, so you're hunting the other sizes, which the review puts at $13 to $15.

Crux Guild Toro Review
The Crux Guild Toro is a Five-Pack (3/4) at about $12.50 street... and the closest a cigar has come to the box without getting one.
The closest a cigar has come to a box here without getting one. The first two thirds are box-quality smoking, the most playable cigar I've had, with the flavor moving between bready, sweet, nutty and baking spice depending on how you pull. The final third makes you manage ash and heat or the bitterness takes over, and that work is what costs it. The exception: at 20 percent off or better, I'm breaking the no-box rule and grabbing one, because at that price the babysitting stops mattering and those first two thirds are too good to walk past.
The ones that look like sale plays and aren't
The receipts on this site show plenty of cigars I got cheap. Most aren't exceptions, and it's worth being clear why.

My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Review
The My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo is a Five-Pack (3/4) at $11.75 to $12.25 street... for this stick, on this night, and just barely over that line.
A Black Friday box worked out to $6.74 a stick, and the review judged it at its roughly $12 street anyway. But this isn't a cigar whose answer changes on sale; the review says my history with it is solidly box behavior, and the stick I reviewed had an off night. The sale is how I bought the box, not why.

Diesel Whiskey Row Toro Review
The Diesel Whiskey Row Toro is a Hand-Me-One (2/4) at about $8 street... a pleasant nutty-bready-coffee smoke through two thirds that never found the...
I paid $4.45 a stick in a sampler and have zero regrets at that number, which is what samplers are for. That's not an exception. The review says I wouldn't spend my own money on another at street, because the profile runs adjacent to what I want and the final third dipped. Cheap doesn't fix where a cigar goes.
Three more reviews say the quiet part out loud. The Liga Privada T52 closes with "nothing about that changes on a deal," because even at ten dollars I'd reach for something else. The Andalusian Bull admits that at $13 to $15 the math would change, but that cigar is never $13, so it's a hypothetical, not a note. And the LecheBurra names the number where it becomes a box for me, about $12, which I paid on a one-time pre-release bundle; no recurring sale sits behind it, so it's a price to watch for rather than wait on.
Three newer reviews name a price too, and none of them is a standing exception. The Diesel Uncaged says I'll probably grab a box if I see one on sale for around $4.50 a stick, which is a price to watch for, not a sale I can count on. The Oliva Master Blends 3 was a perfectly fine deck cigar at the $5 to $7 closeout price I paid, and a closeout doesn't come back. The Mil Días Sublime only says I'll watch for a deal, with no number on it.
Then there's Padrón. The Padrón 2000 carries no exception because none is possible: Padrón is never discounted anywhere, so the shelf price is the price forever, the verdict had to survive at a permanent $9, and the review says it landed where it did partly for that reason.
How to read the deals page against this
A percentage with no anchor is marketing. "70 percent off" tells you about the sticker it was calculated from, and inflated list prices are a standard move in this business. What you want is a verdict plus a real per-stick price, which is why the exception notes above name numbers: about $8 shipped, $5.70 a stick, 20 percent off $12.50. When a discount on one of these three shows up, the math is already done. How to buy cigars covers where sales run, and box splits get you a sale price without twenty of something. Everything else here is a buy-it-or-don't at street, and the Box Buys don't need a sale at all.
More guides
Cigars for a Cold Deck
Reviewed cigars I'd take onto a cold deck: shorter smokes, burns that didn't need babysitting, flavor you don't hunt for, and a lighter that handles wind.
Best Cigars Under $10 I've Actually Smoked
The under-$10 list as it actually stands: what earned a verdict at street price, what's merely fine, and why it's short right now.
The First Five Cigars
Five cigars in a deliberate order, all of them reviewed here. A forgiving start, a step up each time, and a benchmark to measure everything else against.