Guides ›
GuideThe Box Buys
This is the complete list of cigars that have earned a Box Buy... the site's top verdict, judged at street price. It updates itself: the moment a review lands at 4/4, the cigar appears here. No cigar gets on this page any other way.
A Box Buy means exactly what the scale says it means: a box stays on hand at all times, in regular rotation, at the price you'd actually pay. Not "great for the money." Not "great when it's on sale"... sale math gets its own treatment. Great, period, at street.
That's a high bar on purpose, and the list below is short on purpose. Most review sites hand out their top score like a participation ribbon. Here, most cigars I smoke land at a 2 or 3, because most cigars are a 2 or a 3. When something makes this page, that's the whole point of the page.
The list
Padrón Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro Review
The Padrón Family Reserve No. 45 Maduro is a Box Buy (4/4) at about $32 street... it never dipped, never needed a touch-up, and never got boring for...
Arturo Fuente Añejo No. 77 "The Shark" Review
The Arturo Fuente Añejo No. 77 "The Shark" is a Box Buy (4/4) at about $23 street... complex, layered, and phenomenal start to finish, and I'll be...
Perdomo Legacy Nicaraguan Shade-Grown Epicure Review
The Perdomo Legacy Nicaraguan Shade-Grown Epicure is a Box Buy (4/4) at $14 to $14.50 street... sweet cream, roasted cashew, and a baking spice...
Foundation 10 Year Aniversario Salomon Review
The Foundation 10 Year Aniversario Salomon is a Box Buy (4/4) at $35 street... a Mexican hot chocolate of a cigar that stays excellent start to finish...
Foundation The Tabernacle Havana Seed CT No. 142 Toro Review
The Foundation Tabernacle Havana Seed CT No. 142 Toro is a Box Buy (4/4) at $14.50 to $15.50 street... an easy, easy Box Buy, and the next order will...
Perdomo Double Aged 12 Year Vintage Maduro Epicure Review
The Perdomo Double Aged 12 Year Vintage Maduro Epicure is a Box Buy (4/4) at about $12.50 street... I'd spend my own money on this again, no hesitation.
How to use it
Every card links to the full review, and the review is where the reasoning lives... what it tastes like, what it costs, what could have kept it off this list and didn't. Prices quoted in reviews are street prices as of the review date; cigars drift, so check before you buy a box.
And a note on trust: nothing on this site is sponsored, nothing arrives with strings, and every review shows where the stick came from. A short list of real Box Buys is worth more than a long list of maybes... that's the bet this whole site makes.
More guides
The First Five Cigars
Five cigars in a deliberate order, all of them reviewed here. A forgiving start, a step up each time, and a benchmark to measure everything else against.
Cigars for a Round of Golf
What actually belongs in a golf bag: cigars sized to nine or eighteen holes, priced so a cart ride can't hurt you, picked from real reviews on this site.
Best Cigars Under $10 I've Actually Smoked
The under-$10 list as it actually stands: what earned a verdict at street price, what's merely fine, and why it's short right now.