Learn ›
Learn · Smoking BasicsCoffee and Cigars
I take coffee more seriously than almost anyone you know, and I still don't "pair" it with cigars... I make my coffee the way I always make it, and if a morning cigar happens, it's a mild Connecticut alongside. That's the whole system, and there's a reason it's honest to stop there.
My coffee credentials, so the shrug means something
When a coffee guy says pairing charts are overcooked, it matters whether he drinks gas-station drip. So, briefly: I run two grinders... a flat-burr for clarity, a conical for body... a Hario Switch as the daily brewer with a Chemex, V60s, and an AeroPress behind it, a variable-temperature gooseneck kettle, and mineral packets in distilled water because the water is a flavor lever too. As of this summer I roast my own greens at home in 100-gram batches so nothing hits the cup past peak. Every cup gets drunk at the same fixed temperature, on purpose, so days are comparable.
That's a person who cares about flavor variables more than is strictly sane. And here's what that person does when cigars and coffee cross paths: nothing special. I don't have a morning cigar often, but when I do, the coffee is exactly what I'd have made anyway, and the cigar is usually a mild Connecticut shade. No dialed pairing, no matched intensities, no ritual.
Why the coffee nerd doesn't pair
Because I'm chasing two different things, and I know it. When I brew, I'm chasing what's in the cup. When I light a cigar, I'm chasing the cigar's own flavor... that's the entire reason I smoke. Running both at once means each one is stepping on the read of the other, and I'd rather have two clean experiences than one muddy one. When I want a drink, I want a drink. When I want a cigar, I want a cigar.
There's also a site-integrity reason. Every review here is smoked with water so the notes describe the cigar, not the beverage... the reasoning lives on what to drink with a cigar. Building review quantity on a clean palate comes first. Coffee pairing notes may get layered onto reviews down the road, and when that happens it'll be real data from my chair, not chart-copying.
The category problem nobody mentions
Here's the thing my coffee side can say with full confidence: "coffee" is not one flavor, so "coffee pairs with X" is not one claim. A light-roasted washed Ethiopian is bright, tea-like, and citrus-forward. A dark roast is roasty, bitter, and heavy. Those two cups have less in common with each other than a mild Connecticut has with a full maduro... and the pairing charts treat them as a single ingredient. Roast level, origin, process, brew method, even water chemistry move a cup further than most cigars move between thirds. Any pairing rule that starts with the word "coffee," full stop, was written by someone who hasn't tasted very much of it.
So when this site eventually does coffee-pairing work, it'll be specific... this roast, this cigar, this happened... or it won't be worth posting. "Coffee and maduro, name a more iconic duo" is content, not information.
What's actually on the record so far
One data point, disclosed the way everything here is: the Filthy Viking review notes black coffee and a buttered everything bagel before the smoke... before, not during. That's it. That's the site's entire coffee-pairing corpus to date, and it stays that small until doing it properly makes the cut. The how to taste page explains why what you ate an hour ago is already pairing enough.
If you want to try it anyway
Nothing here says don't. Two honest pointers instead of twelve fake ones: a hot bitter drink and a cigar share a lane, so a milder cigar leaves the coffee more room, which is roughly why my hand reaches for a Connecticut on the rare morning it happens. And cream and sugar coat your palate, which softens everything... cigar included... so black keeps the reading clearer. Past that, run your own experiment and trust your own mouth. When I finally run mine, the notes will be on this page.